Maddie Di Muccio's defamation action against John Taylor has been dismissed by the Small Claims Court in Newmarket. Di Muccio had also claimed $5,000 for damage to her reputation.
The Judge, Paul Kupferstein, gives reasons for his judgment here. (Open and scroll to bottom of page).
In his concluding remarks the Judge observes:
"The Plaintiff (Maddie Di Muccio) was, at the relevant time, a public official and ought to have expected full and robust debate of her conduct while in office. The comments and ensuing discussions involved her public persona and public conduct. The Defendant (John Taylor) did not overstep in making the statements he did."
"The Plaintiff's action is dismissed."